indexd. @squat_university
back training

Why a Strong Weightlifter's Back Still Hurt: A Movement Diagnosis Breakdown.

Quick answer

Squat University breaks down a real case study on Carson, an incredibly strong weightlifter who developed back pain despite his strength. Step-by-step spine and hip testing revealed lumbar flexion intolerance, shear load instability, and left hip dysfunction — fixed with the McGill Big 3 routine and hip airplane exercises.

Key takeaways

  • Carson, an incredibly strong weightlifter, felt no pain with a neutral spine under load but immediate pain the moment he flexed his lower back during stool pull tests and light RDLs.
  • Segmental spine testing found one painful level that stopped hurting once Carson lifted both legs to actively stiffen his trunk muscles.
  • Limited internal rotation in Carson's left hip reproduced his familiar hip pain, linking hip dysfunction to his back symptoms.
  • Squat University diagnosed Carson with lumbar flexion intolerance associated with shear load instability and left hip dysfunction.
  • The McGill Big 3 routine (10-second holds) plus hip airplane exercises improved Carson's hip motion and eliminated his end-range pain on retest.
  • The rehab goal wasn't to make Carson's back stronger since he was already strong — it was to make his spine resilient to the specific shearing loads triggering his pain.

Why does a strong lifter like Carson have back pain?

Watch at 0:00

Carson is an incredibly strong weightlifter, yet he developed back pain — proving that raw strength alone doesn't protect the spine from pain in the wrong position. Squat University started the assessment by testing how his spine responded to load rather than assuming weakness was the cause.

With a neutral spine, Carson could pull against a stool with zero pain. The moment he rounded his lower back and repeated the exact same test, the pain came back immediately. The same pattern showed up on a light RDL: neutral spine, no pain; flexed lower back, symptoms return instantly. This positional pattern pointed toward a specific movement diagnosis rather than a generic strength deficit.

How do you test which spine segment causes the pain?

Watch at 0:34

To pinpoint the exact source, Squat University pressed on each segment of Carson's spine individually, creating a shearing load at each level. One specific segment reproduced pain under this test.

The key finding came next: when Carson lifted both legs off the ground — actively stiffening his trunk muscles — the pain at that same segment disappeared. This showed the painful level responds well when the trunk muscles brace and stiffen the spine, rather than needing more raw strength.

Squat University then checked Carson's hips and found limited internal rotation on the left side, which reproduced his familiar hip pain — linking a hip mobility restriction directly to his back symptoms.

What is the movement diagnosis for this type of back pain?

Watch at 1:08

Carson's diagnosis was lumbar flexion intolerance associated with shear load instability and left hip dysfunction — a mouthful, but each part maps to a specific test result. Flexion intolerance explains the pain triggered by rounding the lower back; shear load instability explains the segmental pressing test; hip dysfunction explains the limited internal rotation on the left.

This three-part diagnosis matters because it dictates the exact rehab, rather than a generic "strengthen the back" plan that wouldn't address the real triggers.

How was Carson's back pain fixed?

Watch at 1:13

Squat University resolved Carson's pain with two targeted interventions rather than general back strengthening. He was already incredibly strong, so the goal was making his spine resilient to the specific loads that triggered pain, not adding raw strength.

  1. McGill Big 3 core stability routine — used with 10-second holds to build spine stiffness and address the flexion/shear intolerance.
  2. Hip airplanes — added to restore rotational control in the left hip.

On retest after this program, Carson's hip motion had improved and his end-range pain was gone entirely.

Notable quotes

Carson is an incredibly strong weightlifter, but recently he developed back pain. So if his back is already strong, why did it start hurting?

Squat University 0:00

That told me that painful segment responded better when his trunk muscles stiffened the spine.

Squat University 0:50

The goal won't be to make Carson's back stronger. He's already incredibly strong. The goal is to make his spine more resilient to specific shearing loads that trigger his pain.

Squat University 1:15

Frequently asked questions

Why does a strong weightlifter's back still hurt?

According to Squat University, strength doesn't prevent pain if the spine is loaded in a vulnerable position. Carson, an incredibly strong lifter, had no pain with a neutral spine under load, but pain appeared immediately once he rounded his lower back during the same tests — showing the issue was positional tolerance, not overall back strength.

What is lumbar flexion intolerance?

Lumbar flexion intolerance is a movement diagnosis where the lower back becomes painful specifically when flexed or rounded under load, but stays pain-free in a neutral position. Squat University identified this in Carson using stool pull tests and light RDLs: neutral spine produced no pain, while rounding the lower back reproduced his symptoms every time.

How do you test which spinal segment is causing back pain?

Squat University pressed on each vertebral segment individually to create a shearing load and find the painful level. One specific segment was painful on its own, but when Carson lifted both legs off the ground to stiffen his trunk muscles, that same segment's pain disappeared — showing the segment responds well when the trunk actively stabilizes it.

What exercises help with shear-related low back pain?

Squat University used the McGill Big 3 core stability routine with 10-second holds to build spine stiffness, plus hip airplanes to restore hip rotational control. After this program, Carson's limited hip internal rotation improved and his end-range back pain resolved on retesting.

Can hip problems cause lower back pain?

Yes — in Carson's case, limited internal rotation in his left hip reproduced his familiar hip pain during testing, and Squat University linked this hip dysfunction directly to his back pain diagnosis. Adding hip airplane exercises to restore rotational control was part of resolving his symptoms, alongside spine stiffness work.

Is the goal of back pain rehab to make the back stronger?

Not necessarily, according to Squat University: Carson was already incredibly strong, so building more raw back strength wasn't the point. The actual goal was making his spine more resilient to the specific shearing loads that triggered his pain, achieved through targeted core stiffness and hip mobility work rather than generic strengthening.

Full transcript

0:00Case intro: a strong lifter with back pain

Carson is an incredibly strong weightlifter, but recently he developed back pain. So if his back is already strong, why did it start hurting? I started by seeing how his spine responded to load. With a neutral spine, he could pull up against a stool with no pain.

But the moment he rounded his lower back and repeated the test, his pain immediately came out. I saw the exact same thing with a light RDL. With a neutral spine, no pain. However, the instant he flexed his lower back, the symptoms came right back.

Next, I pressed on each segment of his spine, creating a shearing load. One level was painful, but when I asked him to lift both legs off the ground, that pain disappeared. That told me that painful segment responded better when his trunk muscles stiffened the spine. Finally, I checked his hips and found limited internal rotation on the left that also reproduced his familiar hip pain.

So this meant his movement diagnosis was lumbar flexion intolerance associated with shear load instability and left hip dysfunction. I started him on the McGill Big 3 core stability routine using 10-second holds to improve spine stiffness. Then we added hip airplanes to restore hip rotational control. When I retested him after, his hip motion improved and his end-range pain was now gone.

The goal won't be to make Carson's back stronger. He's already incredibly strong. The goal is to make his spine more resilient to specific shearing loads that trigger his pain.

0:08Testing spine flexion tolerance with load

0:34Segmental shear testing and leg-lift retest

0:58Hip internal rotation and pain link

1:08Diagnosis: lumbar flexion intolerance + hip dysfunction

1:13Fixing it: McGill Big 3 and hip airplanes

Mentioned in this video

Organizations
  • Squat University
  • Muscle and Motion
People
  • Dr. Aaron Horschig
  • Carson Johnson
Concepts
  • McGill Big 3
  • Hip airplanes
  • RDL (Romanian Deadlift)
  • Lumbar flexion intolerance
  • Shear load instability